Apple Pie Ice Cream Topped With Caramel Sauce

This post may contain affiliate links. Please read my full disclosure here. This site uses cookies to provide a better user experience. See more about my privacy & cookies policy here. is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to
Jump to recipe(Last Updated On: June 28, 2018)

I am not a pumpkin pie kinda girl. Apple pie is more to my liking. This year for Thanksgiving, I decided to skip the pie all together and serve up Apple Pie Ice Cream topped with delicious caramel sauce instead. It tastes exactly like a slice of apple pie topped with vanilla ice cream and caramel sauce, only with half the work.

Apple Pie Ice Cream Topped With Caramel Sauce

You can use any ice cream maker to make apple pie ice cream. Just make sure to follow the freezing instructions for the unit you own. I used our Zoku Ice Cream Makers which freezes a bowl of ice cream in just 10 minutes. I really love our instant freeze Zoku ice cream bowls for making yummy desserts at the last minute or when we have unexpected guests because I can whip up a batch of ice cream in less than 15 minutes.

This apple pie ice cream is very easy to make and you only need a few basic ingredients including milk, cream, sugar, cinnamon, apples and graham crackers to get started. To get the authentic apple pie flavor infused into the ice cream, I cooked the apples in sugar and cinnamon until they were soft and tender. The cooked apples taste just like the filling in an apple pie. To replicate the flavor of the pie crust, I used graham crackers. I then blended the cooked apples and graham crackers into the milk and cream and froze the mixture in our Zoku Ice Cream Makers.

Apple Pie Ice Cream Topped With Caramel Sauce

I topped our apple pie ice cream using the Pioneer Woman’s easy caramel sauce recipe. It is super easy to make, fool-proof and tastes absolutely delicious. I could seriously eat this stuff by the spoonfuls, it is that good! If you don’t want to make your own, you could pick up a jar of caramel sauce from the grocery store instead.

Apple Pie Ice Cream Topped With Caramel Sauce

Tip: It is very important to work with the coldest ingredients possible when making ice cream. I like to put my milk and cream mixtures back into the fridge for at least 30 minutes after mixing to ensure they are at their coldest before adding to the ice cream maker. The same goes for the add-ins. The cooked apples need to be completely cooled before adding to the ice cream otherwise you will end up with little melted pockets of ice cream that don’t freeze properly. I also like to put the graham crackers and nuts (if you are using) in the fridge too so all the ingredients are extra cold.

Apple Pie Ice Cream Topped With Caramel Sauce

This post is part of the Pinterest Party Thanksgiving Blog Hop. Pinterest Party is a Facebook group for pinners who love to collaborate and share. If you’re gathering ideas for Thanksgiving, be sure to follow along as each post is published. Here’s the schedule:

October 18 How to Cook a Turkey for Thanksgiving

October 19 Thanksgiving Hostess Gift Idea – Autumn Ribbon Pine Cone

October 20 Test Your Thanksgiving Food Safety Skill Now With This Quiz

October 21 Apple Pie Ice Cream (that’s me)

October 22  Pumpkin Shortbread

October 23 Thanksgiving Stuffing Recipe

October 24 Easy Pumpkin Pie Recipe

October 25  Unique Thanksgiving Cake Decorating Ideas

October 26 Classic Cranberry Pecan Bread

October 27  Deviled Eggs Recipe

October 28 Beautiful Table Linens for Thanksgiving

One thought on “Apple Pie Ice Cream Topped With Caramel Sauce

  1. Holy bonkers that looks and sounds so good! What kind of apples do you like to use for this? We typically put Granny Smith in pies just because that’s the way hubby’s mama does it and she is the one who taught me how to make pie.

Comments are closed.